This quote is from the legendary Charlie Kirk, who is described as "Mediocre" in both physical and mental capabilities. He reflects on thinking he might be smarter than Michelle Obama and Ketanji Brown Jackson.
Title: The Misleading View of Intelligence in Black Women: Charlie Kirk's Perspective on College SuccessIn recent months, Charlie Kirk has sparked a heated debate by suggesting that prominent Black women in fields such as education, media, and technology do not possess the cognitive abilities required for high-quality colleges. While his perspective is timely, it oversimplifies complex issues of race, intelligence, and opportunity. This article examines Kirk's claim, analyzing other factors that could influence someone's ability to succeed academically.
---
### The Context of Charlie Kirk's Thought
Charlie Kirk, a community college dropout, has been the subject of viral debates online due to his personal struggles and achievements. His narrative often centers on Black women in education, emphasizing their potential despite systemic barriers. He argues that "prominent Black women did not have the 'brain processing power' needed for good colleges," citing examples like university entrance exams as evidence. While his voice resonates with many, this claim is oversimplified.
### Michelle Obama: A Path Less Traveled
Michelle Obama, a prominent U.S. Secretary of State and civil rights leader, has faced significant challenges due to her family's poverty and race. Despite these obstacles, she has achieved remarkable success—elected to the U.S. Department of State in 2013, becoming the first woman to serve in that role. Obama's narrative highlights progress despite systemic inequalities, but her story does not represent the typical Black women's experiences.
### Ketanji Brown Jackson: A Path Forward
Ketanji Brown Jackson is a black woman who overcame racial and gender barriers in the tech industry before becoming a civil rights activist. Her journey reflects resilience and opportunity. However, while she has achieved significant milestones, her perspective does not align with the generalizability of Kirk's claims.
---
### Arguing Against the Premise
The premise that prominent Black women lack intelligence to attend good colleges is an oversimplification. Key factors like motivation, school environment, access to resources, social support, and cultural influences significantly influence educational outcomes:
1. Motivation vs. Fixed Shapley Games: Kirk's focus on brainpower overlooks the role of personal ambition and resilience. Success often arises from driven individuals who persist despite challenges.
2. Quality of Education: Many Black women have access to quality institutions through community colleges or higher education, despite systemic barriers. Their potential is not limited by background alone.
3. Access to Resources: Opportunities for education are often available in under-resourced schools, and access can vary widely based on initial circumstances.
4. Social Support: Families play a crucial role in providing resources and environment conducive to academic success.
5. Cultural Beliefs: Society's perception of intelligence is shaped by systemic biases, where some believe Black women lack the potential for academic excellence.
6. Societal Pressure: Societal pressures from family structures, education systems, and employment opportunities can influence choices about academic paths.
---
### Conclusion
Kirk's claim does not represent a comprehensive view of Black women's educational journeys. It conflates factors like intelligence with systemic barriers that often override individual capabilities. To better understand the experiences of Black women in education, it is essential to consider these multifaceted factors rather than focusing solely on intelligence. The rise and success of Black women in various fields demonstrate that opportunity, support, and perseverance can lead to extraordinary achievements, irrespective of societal perceptions.
By examining Kirk's perspective while acknowledging other influences, we gain a more nuanced understanding of Black women's paths to success.
------
